Elisha Renner

Born: about 1801 in Virginia
Died: about 1866 in Rockcastle County, Kentucky

In the censuses Elisha says he was born in VA and his children also say their father was born in VA. That doesn't perfectly fit with Adam's death record, but the disagreement is small, only a year or two. Either Adam's family's memory or an error in Elisha's age in the census could account for the discrepancy.

Elisha married Sarah Decker about 1838; he apparently lived with his father Jacob until the latter's death (he looks to be in Jacob's household in 1830), marrying at an older-than-average age. There is no evidence of a wife prior to Sarah, although it's possible he was married before. [Update: Based on evidence in an 1833 land document, he was married to a woman named Ann at that time. It's unclear whether Elisha and Ann had children, but it's possible the two oldest children could have been from this union. It's also possible they had girls, the names of whom we don't know.] He and Sarah had two boys (Henry B and John G) and two girls (Malinda and Margaret). Henry B, who was a successful farmer in Rockcastle and Pulaski in later years, is the only child who we know anything substantial about.

There are persistent family stories which indicate Elisha may be the father of Ingram Renner, but the stories are confusing and aren't consistent from one telling to the next.

In 1834, Elisha lived in the "old Renner cabin" on Buffalo Branch Road. He had moved by 1839, probably just south to the Decker farm, which was also on Buffalo Branch about a mile away. Sarah's widowed mother, Rhoda, was living in Elisha's household in the 1860 census. A map showing the Decker land and Renner cabin is here.

An analysis of the census records indicates Elisha lived in the Line Creek area most of his life.

There are no records which show Elisha owning land, although he paid taxes on 130 acres of land on Skeggs Creek in 1835, grant in the name of Renner. 1835 was an aberrant year for Adam as well. What's even more interesting is that John is not on the 1835 tax list at all, but in 1837 (data for 1836 is missing) he's back with 220 acres. Perhaps, for some unknown-to-us reason, Adam and Elisha paid the taxes on John's land in 1835.

Elisha's last year on the tax list is 1865; in 1867 Sarah appears for the first time.

Like the other older Renners, Elisha has no gravestone. He and Sarah are probably buried with the Deckers in an unknown cemetery on Buffalo Branch.